How to Replace a Broken Roof Tile

One broken roof tile may seem harmless, but it can escalate into a larger issue, such as leaks, mould, or damage to your ceiling. Tiles can break from strong winds, storms, falling branches, or wear and tear over time. Even someone stepping on the roof during a repair can crack one without noticing. That’s why it’s better to fix it early. You don’t always need to repair the whole roof; sometimes, replacing that single tile is all it takes to stop the problem.

Signs Your Roof Tiles Need Replacing

Here are some easy signs to look out for:

• You can see a tile that’s broken or missing.
• Some tiles have slipped out of place.
• You find pieces of tile in your gutters.
• You notice water marks or damp spots inside your house, especially on the ceilings.
• Your roof looks uneven or patchy from the ground.

If you see any of these, it’s worth checking closer or calling someone who can.

Step-by-Step: How to Replace a Broken Roof Tile

Step 1: Get to the Roof Safely

Use a sturdy ladder and place it on flat, solid ground. Have someone hold the ladder while you climb. Keep your hands free using a tool belt or pouch to carry everything you need. Never rush, take your time, and stay balanced.

Step 2: Remove the Broken Tile

Once you’re on the roof and you’ve found the broken tile, take a close look at how it’s fitted. 

• Carefully lift the tiles that overlap it (usually the ones above). You can use a flat pry bar or a similar tool.
• Gently slide the tool under the broken tile and lift it out. 
• Be careful not to crack or shift the surrounding tiles. If the broken tile is nailed down, try to remove or cut the nail before pulling the tile free.

Step 3: Slide in the New Tile

Now, take your replacement tile. Before installing it, make sure it matches the shape and size of the old one. If it’s slightly too big, you might need to trim it.
Slide the new tile into the gap where the old one was. Line it up so it sits evenly with the other tiles. It should rest flat and not stick up or down more than the others.

Step 4: Secure the Tile

Depending on your roof, tiles can be secured in different ways.

• If nails were used, re-nail the new tile in the same spot.
• If it uses clips, reattach them to hold it in place.
• If adhesive was used before, apply a fresh dab of roof-safe adhesive to the back and press the tile down gently.

Don’t force it. You want it snug and steady, tight enough that it won’t move but not so tight that it cracks.

Step 5: Check the surrounding tiles for any loose

While you’re already on the roof, it’s a smart move to check the area around the repair. Look for loose, cracked, or shifted tiles. Give them a light tap if they wiggle or sound hollow. They might need fixing. Catching these now could save you another trip up the ladder later.

How to Replace Different Types of Roof Tiles

Sometimes, the method changes slightly depending on the tile type or its location on your roof.  If you’re not sure what kind of tile you need, take a broken one to a local roofing store or builder’s merchant. They can help you find the right type.

Here’s a quick guide:

Cracked or Chipped Tile

A cracked roof tile is much simpler in terms of repairs. To prevent leaks, apply roof sealant along the crack. If a tile just has a small crack and it’s still in place, you don’t always need to replace it.
Here’s what you can do:

• For small cracks: Use roof sealant or adhesive to stop water from getting through.
• For bigger cracks or loose tiles: It’s better to remove the damaged one and fit a new tile.

Vertical Roof Tiles and Slates

These are often found on the sides or top of dormer walls. To replace one:

• Remove the old nails.
• Slide out the tile.
• Fit a new one and secure it with nails or clips.

Ridge and Hip Tiles

These tiles run along the top of your roof or down the corners and are often set in place with mortar.
To replace:

• Gently chip away the old mortar around the tile.
• Lift the damaged tile off.
• Put fresh mortar in and press the new tile down firmly.

Concrete or Clay Plain Tiles

These are flat and laid in rows.

• Lift the tile above the broken one.
• Remove the broken tile.
• Slide in the new one and secure it.

Slate Roof Tiles

Slate is very fragile, so handle it with care.

• Use a slate ripper to cut the nails behind the broken tile.
• Slide in a new one.
• Nail it down and cover the nail with a small metal tab (so water can’t get in).

When to Call a Professional Roofer

If you’re not comfortable working at heights or if the damage is too large to handle on your own, don’t take unnecessary risks. That’s when it’s time to call someone who knows what they’re doing.

If you need reliable roofing services in Hereford or nearby areas, RBG Hereford Roofers is here to help. From single tile repairs to complex roofing work, the professional team provides dependable service with the right tools and expert care.

Conclusion 

Fixing a broken roof tile might seem like a small job, but it makes a big difference in keeping your home dry and damage-free. If caught early, you can replace just the damaged tile and avoid bigger problems like leaks or mould. Whether you’re comfortable doing it yourself or prefer to call a Professional roofer, taking action early is the best way to protect your roof and your home.

FAQs